SafeRedact vs PDF-XChange
PDF-XChange is a budget-friendly PDF editor with redaction features. SafeRedact is purpose-built for redaction with AI-powered detection.
- ✓ Automatic PII detection
- ✓ Browser-based
- ✓ From $5/day
- ✓ Free tier
- ✓ Mac/Windows/Linux
- ✓ Full PDF editing
- ✓ Manual redaction
- ✓ Desktop (Windows)
- ✓ $56 one-time (Plus)
- • Windows only
Feature Comparison
| Feature | SafeRedact | PDF-XChange |
|---|---|---|
| AI PII Detection | ✓ | ✗ |
| Manual Redaction | ✓ | ✓ (Plus only) |
| Search & Redact | ✓ | ✓ |
| Permanent Removal | ✓ | ✓ |
| Full PDF Editing | ✗ | ✓ |
| Browser-Based | ✓ | ✗ |
| Mac Support | ✓ | ✗ Windows only |
| Free Tier | ✓ | ◐ Limited free version |
Key Considerations
PDF-XChange Requires "Plus" for Redaction
The standard PDF-XChange Editor ($46) does not include redaction. You need PDF-XChange Editor Plus ($56) for redaction features. Make sure you get the right version.
Windows Only
PDF-XChange is Windows-only software. Mac and Linux users cannot use it. SafeRedact works in any modern browser on any operating system.
Manual vs. Automatic Detection
PDF-XChange requires you to manually find and select content to redact. SafeRedact's AI automatically scans for SSNs, phone numbers, addresses, names, and other PII—reducing the risk of missing something.
Where Your Document Goes
The biggest difference? What happens to your sensitive files.
Stored & processed remotely
Not stored · Clean file in browser
Privacy and Data Handling
How each tool handles your sensitive documents during the redaction process.
PDF-XChange Editor
- •Desktop app processes locally
- •Requires software installation
- •May sync with cloud features
- •IT department may need to approve
SafeRedact
- •100% browser-based processing
- •Files never leave your device
- •Only extracted text sent for AI
- •Zero-trust architecture
Detection Capabilities Compared
The technology behind each tool determines what gets found and what gets missed.
What PDF-XChange Editor Detects
Pattern-based detection requires you to define search terms:
- ✓ SSNs in standard format
- ✓ Phone numbers (standard formats)
- ✗ Names (manual entry required)
- ✗ Addresses (manual entry required)
What SafeRedact Detects
AI understands context and meaning:
- ✓ Names in any format
- ✓ Addresses (full or partial)
- ✓ All ID number formats
- ✓ Context-dependent PII
Time and Cost Analysis
Beyond the sticker price, consider the true cost of each solution.
| Factor | PDF-XChange Editor | SafeRedact |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing | $56/year | $4.99 day pass / $99/year |
| Time per document | 10-30 min (manual review) | ~30 seconds (AI-powered) |
| Setup required | Software installation | None (browser-based) |
| Free option | Limited trial | Unlimited (watermark) |
Bottom Line: SafeRedact AI detection can save hours of manual review time. The $4.99 day pass is often more cost-effective than annual subscriptions for occasional use.
Pricing Comparison
SafeRedact
- Demo: Free
- Day Pass: $5/day
- Annual: $99/year
Subscription. Cancel anytime.
PDF-XChange Editor Plus
- Perpetual: $56 one-time
- Maintenance: Optional annual fee
One-time purchase. Windows only.
Try AI-Powered Redaction
Works on Mac, Windows, and Linux. Free to start.
Start Redacting →